#62256: "BGA not applying penalties for deception/misleading other player in P.I."
В какво се състои този доклад?
Какво се случи? Моля изберете от списъка по-долу
Какво се случи? Моля изберете от списъка по-долу
Моля, проверете дали вече има доклад по същия въпрос
Ако отговорът е „да“, моля, гласувайте за този доклад. Отчетите с най-много гласове са дадени ПРИОРИТЕТ!
| # | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
|---|
Подробно описание
-
• Моля поставете тук съобщението за грешка което виждате, ако има такова
The BGA game is not applying the penalty for misleading information. Taking another players cards to mislead them is vetoed by the rules but allowed on BGA. The offending player ought to forfeit the round and the impeded player get 7 points. This is described in the official rules on page 8 of the pdf:
"misleading Information: If it becomes apparent that a player has accidently misled another player then a penalty is imposed. The player who gave incorrect information scores zero points for this mini-game while the misled player scores seven points. Points counters should be moved accordingly. As both players have scored then they take no more actions in this mini game." -
• Моля обяснете, какво искахте да направите, какво направихте и какво се случи
See move 28 of the game here: boardgamearena.com/gamereview?table=256309640 This prevented solving the case in move 33 but no penalty is applied and the offending player took all the points, in fact I got penalised for an incorrect guess.
• Какъв е вашия браузър?
Mozilla v5
-
• Моля копирайте/поставете текстът показан на аглийски, вместо на Вашия език. If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use a picture hosting service of your choice (snipboard.io for example) to upload it and copy/paste the link here. Наличен ли е този текст в системата за превод? Ако да, бил ли е преведен за повече от 24 часа?
The BGA game is not applying the penalty for misleading information. Taking another players cards to mislead them is vetoed by the rules but allowed on BGA. The offending player ought to forfeit the round and the impeded player get 7 points. This is described in the official rules on page 8 of the pdf:
"misleading Information: If it becomes apparent that a player has accidently misled another player then a penalty is imposed. The player who gave incorrect information scores zero points for this mini-game while the misled player scores seven points. Points counters should be moved accordingly. As both players have scored then they take no more actions in this mini game." • Какъв е вашия браузър?
Mozilla v5
-
• Моля обяснете вашето придложение ясно и кратко така че да бъде възможно най-разбираемо.
The BGA game is not applying the penalty for misleading information. Taking another players cards to mislead them is vetoed by the rules but allowed on BGA. The offending player ought to forfeit the round and the impeded player get 7 points. This is described in the official rules on page 8 of the pdf:
"misleading Information: If it becomes apparent that a player has accidently misled another player then a penalty is imposed. The player who gave incorrect information scores zero points for this mini-game while the misled player scores seven points. Points counters should be moved accordingly. As both players have scored then they take no more actions in this mini game." • Какъв е вашия браузър?
Mozilla v5
-
• Какво е било показано на екрана, когато сте били блокирани (празен екран? Част от интерфейса на играта? Съобщение за грешка?)
The BGA game is not applying the penalty for misleading information. Taking another players cards to mislead them is vetoed by the rules but allowed on BGA. The offending player ought to forfeit the round and the impeded player get 7 points. This is described in the official rules on page 8 of the pdf:
"misleading Information: If it becomes apparent that a player has accidently misled another player then a penalty is imposed. The player who gave incorrect information scores zero points for this mini-game while the misled player scores seven points. Points counters should be moved accordingly. As both players have scored then they take no more actions in this mini game." • Какъв е вашия браузър?
Mozilla v5
-
• Коя част от правилата не е била спазена от BGA адаптацията
The BGA game is not applying the penalty for misleading information. Taking another players cards to mislead them is vetoed by the rules but allowed on BGA. The offending player ought to forfeit the round and the impeded player get 7 points. This is described in the official rules on page 8 of the pdf:
"misleading Information: If it becomes apparent that a player has accidently misled another player then a penalty is imposed. The player who gave incorrect information scores zero points for this mini-game while the misled player scores seven points. Points counters should be moved accordingly. As both players have scored then they take no more actions in this mini game." -
• Нарушенията на правилата видими ли са при повторение на играта? Ако да, на кой ход се случват?
See move 28 of the game here: boardgamearena.com/gamereview?table=256309640 This prevented solving the case in move 33 but no penalty is applied and the offending player took all the points, in fact I got penalised for an incorrect guess.
• Какъв е вашия браузър?
Mozilla v5
-
• Какъв бе игровият ход, който се опитахте да извършите?
The BGA game is not applying the penalty for misleading information. Taking another players cards to mislead them is vetoed by the rules but allowed on BGA. The offending player ought to forfeit the round and the impeded player get 7 points. This is described in the official rules on page 8 of the pdf:
"misleading Information: If it becomes apparent that a player has accidently misled another player then a penalty is imposed. The player who gave incorrect information scores zero points for this mini-game while the misled player scores seven points. Points counters should be moved accordingly. As both players have scored then they take no more actions in this mini game." -
• Какво се опитвате да направите, за да задействате тази игра?
See move 28 of the game here: boardgamearena.com/gamereview?table=256309640 This prevented solving the case in move 33 but no penalty is applied and the offending player took all the points, in fact I got penalised for an incorrect guess.
-
• Какво се случи, когато се опитахте да направите това (съобщение за грешка, съобщение за статуса на играта, ...)?
• Какъв е вашия браузър?
Mozilla v5
-
• В кой момент от играта се появи проблема (каква е била съответната инструкция в играта)?
The BGA game is not applying the penalty for misleading information. Taking another players cards to mislead them is vetoed by the rules but allowed on BGA. The offending player ought to forfeit the round and the impeded player get 7 points. This is described in the official rules on page 8 of the pdf:
"misleading Information: If it becomes apparent that a player has accidently misled another player then a penalty is imposed. The player who gave incorrect information scores zero points for this mini-game while the misled player scores seven points. Points counters should be moved accordingly. As both players have scored then they take no more actions in this mini game." -
• Какво се случи, когато се опитахте да извършите действието в играта (съобщение за грешка, съобщение за статуса на играта, ...)?
See move 28 of the game here: boardgamearena.com/gamereview?table=256309640 This prevented solving the case in move 33 but no penalty is applied and the offending player took all the points, in fact I got penalised for an incorrect guess.
• Какъв е вашия браузър?
Mozilla v5
-
• Моля опишете грешката при изобразяването If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use a picture hosting service of your choice (snipboard.io for example) to upload it and copy/paste the link here.
The BGA game is not applying the penalty for misleading information. Taking another players cards to mislead them is vetoed by the rules but allowed on BGA. The offending player ought to forfeit the round and the impeded player get 7 points. This is described in the official rules on page 8 of the pdf:
"misleading Information: If it becomes apparent that a player has accidently misled another player then a penalty is imposed. The player who gave incorrect information scores zero points for this mini-game while the misled player scores seven points. Points counters should be moved accordingly. As both players have scored then they take no more actions in this mini game." • Какъв е вашия браузър?
Mozilla v5
-
• Моля копирайте/поставете текстът показан на аглийски, вместо на Вашия език. If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use a picture hosting service of your choice (snipboard.io for example) to upload it and copy/paste the link here. Наличен ли е този текст в системата за превод? Ако да, бил ли е преведен за повече от 24 часа?
The BGA game is not applying the penalty for misleading information. Taking another players cards to mislead them is vetoed by the rules but allowed on BGA. The offending player ought to forfeit the round and the impeded player get 7 points. This is described in the official rules on page 8 of the pdf:
"misleading Information: If it becomes apparent that a player has accidently misled another player then a penalty is imposed. The player who gave incorrect information scores zero points for this mini-game while the misled player scores seven points. Points counters should be moved accordingly. As both players have scored then they take no more actions in this mini game." • Какъв е вашия браузър?
Mozilla v5
-
• Моля обяснете вашето придложение ясно и кратко така че да бъде възможно най-разбираемо.
The BGA game is not applying the penalty for misleading information. Taking another players cards to mislead them is vetoed by the rules but allowed on BGA. The offending player ought to forfeit the round and the impeded player get 7 points. This is described in the official rules on page 8 of the pdf:
"misleading Information: If it becomes apparent that a player has accidently misled another player then a penalty is imposed. The player who gave incorrect information scores zero points for this mini-game while the misled player scores seven points. Points counters should be moved accordingly. As both players have scored then they take no more actions in this mini game." • Какъв е вашия браузър?
Mozilla v5
История на докладванията
At the very least BGA should prevent players taking cards they know to belong to their opponents when they receive them in their starting hands.
As for the reproach which you make to your opponent to choose a card of your case, it is not based on the rules and in the example which you give on move #28, you did not need this card as the crime of your case could already be deduced from the hints on the boardgame at that time.
Considering the beginning of the referenced game, I think your level of play is much too low for you to enjoy playing P. I. in real time.
Not a bug.
Taking cards that are valuable for your neighbor but not for you is not only not forbidden by the rules, it can actually be part of a strategy.
Добави нещо към този доклад
- Друга маса ID / Ход ID
- F5 реши ли проблема?
- Проблемът няколко пъти ли се е появил? Или всеки път? Или абсолютно случайно?
- If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use a picture hosting service of your choice (snipboard.io for example) to upload it and copy/paste the link here.
