Докладвай • Board Game Arena

Всички доклади

thirtyone_displayed доклади

#127276: "Stalemate situation "

implemented: Това предложение бе изпълнено

В какво се състои този доклад?

thirtyone #524830611

Какво се случи? Моля изберете от списъка по-долу

Предложение: според мен, следното ще подобри значително изпълнението на играта

Какво се случи? Моля изберете от списъка по-долу

Предложение: според мен, следното ще подобри значително изпълнението на играта

Моля, проверете дали вече има доклад по същия въпрос

Ако отговорът е „да“, моля, гласувайте за този доклад. Отчетите с най-много гласове са дадени ПРИОРИТЕТ!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Подробно описание

История на докладванията

Jun 13 th 2024 19:08 • NnSshared • Това предложение все още не е анализирано от разработчиците:

No other info

Jun 13 th 2024 20:18 • ufm • Разработчиците смятат, че това не е добра идея, или че съотношението цена/полезно действие е твърде високо:

You have to close the round to get out of the loop.

Jun 26 th 2024 00:44 • Zeus • Разработчиците смятат, че това не е добра идея, или че съотношението цена/полезно действие е твърде високо:

no it's a very specific scenario where somebody intentionally shuffles to not pass along, and would just grab the 3rd card if the other person closed the round. it can happen that neither player is incentivized to progress the game. would be nice to have a tie offer for these scenarios, they happen somewhat frequently at higher levels - look at this scenario in the round where i am 3-1 ahead: boardgamearena.com/table?table=524830611. i know they have 2 spades, so if i gave them the 8s, they would likely win, so i have to shuffle the hearts instead because passing along would allow them to gain an edge as they would be first to play. in games with a high level friend of mine, we just agree to a tie after a few shuffles, but there should be a better option.

in order for people to not endlessly shuffle anyway, an automatic end of the round if x number of exchanges happen with no progress should also be implemented / added as an optional setting.

Jun 26 th 2024 03:19 • ufm • Разработчиците смятат, че това не е добра идея, или че съотношението цена/полезно действие е твърде високо:

Closing the round has nothing to do with the next round's first player.

Jun 26 th 2024 03:30 • Zeus • Разработчиците смятат, че това не е добра идея, или че съотношението цена/полезно действие е твърде високо:

i am aware, what i said is in reference to me not being incentivized to pass along - when he passes, and i pass along, the 3 middle cards are exchanged and it would be his turn first and he so he can take the desired cards. thats why shuffling is the superior move - its a flaw in the game, because it is a stalemate where both players should not progress.

getting an anti-stalemate option would be big for that reason.

in most casual games, it doesn't matter and people will progress to not be annoying, but if played competitively / optimally, this will come up and needs a better solution.

Jun 26 th 2024 03:38 • ufm • Разработчиците смятат, че това не е добра идея, или че съотношението цена/полезно действие е твърде високо:

Then close the round... Closing is not equivalent to passing.

Jun 26 th 2024 03:43 • Focus • Разработчиците смятат, че това не е добра идея, или че съотношението цена/полезно действие е твърде високо:

i agree that adding an option to agree to tie the round and/or blocking people from endlessly shuffling in order to block a pass would improve the game

Jun 26 th 2024 03:52 • Zeus • Разработчиците смятат, че това не е добра идея, или че съотношението цена/полезно действие е твърде високо:

nobody can close profitably there - if you check the scenario from the replay, NnSshared became annoyed and closed, and I then exchanged and won the round.
if played optimally (and he knew that too), he had to continue passing there, and I had to continue shuffling, because I don't have enough to close and win (knowing he has at least 17), and if I did exchange the 8 of Spades, then he could take it and would likely win.

his best move: passing
my best move: shuffling 2 cards

this should be repeated endlessly with optimal play. closing is not an option that either of us can take if we wanted to win. it's an option that progresses the game, but it doesn't favor either player. with good players this happens fairly often and is unavoidable.

Adding a "tie offer" would be great and something most honorable players would want - and an extra optional setting to protect yourself against people potentially abusing it "round automatically closes after 20 moves without progress" would be great.

People could virtually just sit there and shuffle cards, and wait for the other person to get bored / give up. I've had similar scenarios with many players, where nothing but the same exchanges were done for 10 minutes and draw offers via chat were ignored.

Jun 26 th 2024 04:27 • ufm • Това предложение бе изпълнено:

Ok, added automatic closure rule.
If the round does not end after surviving player count x 10 moves after the last card draw (either by round start or fresh draw after all players pass), the round instantly ends.

Jun 30 th 2024 06:15 • ufm • Това предложение бе изпълнено:

Changed to 15 x player count

Добави нещо към този доклад

Моля, добавете тук всичко, което изглежда подходящо, за да възпроизведете този бъг или да разберете вашето предложение:

Друга маса ID / Ход ID
F5 реши ли проблема?
Проблемът няколко пъти ли се е появил? Или всеки път? Или абсолютно случайно?
If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use a picture hosting service of your choice (snipboard.io for example) to upload it and copy/paste the link here.

Откажи Актуализирайте доклада

#127276: "Stalemate situation "

В какво се състои този доклад?

Какво се случи? Моля изберете от списъка по-долу

Какво се случи? Моля изберете от списъка по-долу

Моля, проверете дали вече има доклад по същия въпрос

Подробно описание

История на докладванията

Добави нещо към този доклад

Промени статуса на доклада на:

Помощ

Допринеси

Навигиране

Последвайте ни